Bangladesh
Every Drop Counts: managing a mega city water crisis
by I. M
Faisal
e-mail:msdh@bdcom.com
The crisis
The
Ancient Manner of Coleridge was stranded in the deep sea, sighing for a drop of
fresh water that would save his life. Who could think that centuries later,
standing at the doorstep of the 21st century, humanity would be facing the same
crisis and that too in the middle of a modern city? The people of Dhaka are too
familiar with the dried up water taps and long lines with pitchers and buckets
in front of a water tanker. Water is one commodity that no living thing can do
without.
Early in the 20th century, Dhaka was a sleepy little
provincial town with a population of only about 90 thousand. However, after the
birth of Pakistan in 1947 and designation of Dhaka as the capital of East
Pakistan, the city began to grow at a fast rate. By 1951, the population of
Dhaka grew to about 276,000, increasing nearly three times in 50 years. The
current population of Dhaka is about eight million, representing a nearly
30-fold increase of population since 1951. This can truly be described as a
population explosion for the capital city. It is projected that by the year
2010, the city will join the Mega City club, boasting a population of over 10
million.
This runaway population implies increasing demands for
basic city services -- the most important one being the demand for a safe and
reliable water supply. Currently this growing demand is being met primarily by
pumping water from the aquifers under the city. However, the groundwater reserve
is rapidly declining and the progress in tapping surface water sources has been
very slow. In other words, the looming threat of a serious water crisis in the
city is becoming a real one with each passing day.
DWASA
To address the
need for safe water and sanitation, Dhaka Water Supply and Sewerage Authority
(DWASA) was set up in 1963 (before independence it was called EPWASA). Since
then, DWASA has grown considerably in size and capacity. Currently, from a
network of some 237 deep tubewells and the water treatment plants at
Chandnighat, Goadlyle and Sonakanda, DWASA produces over 0.9 Mm3 of water per
day and serves some four million people through its piped water supply
system.
DWASA at a glance
| Facility/service |
Quantity |
| Deep
tubewell |
237
|
| Water production | 0.93
Mm3/day |
| Treatment plant | 3
|
| Water lines | 1610
km |
| Connections |
171,855 |
| Overhead tanks | 38
|
| Roadside tap | 1643
|
The ever-growing deficit
Despite
significant expansion of the service area of DWASA since 1990, the gap between
the demand and the supply of water is likely to grow in the future. The chart
below shows how these figures are likely to change in the coming decades.
Box 2: Demand and supply
(Mm3 per day)
|
Year | Demand | Supply |
Deficit |
| 1990 | 1.67 | 0.51 | 1.16 |
| 1996 | 2.07 | 0.81 | 1.26 |
| 2000 | 2.62 | 0.95 | 1.67 |
| 2010 | 3.33 | 1.40 | 1.93 |
| 2020 | 4.60 | 1.85 2.75 |
In making the
projections above, it was assumed that the per capita water use in Dhaka would
reach 220 liters/day in 2020. In 1990, this was 150 liters/day and currently it
is about 180 liters/day.
It was also assumed that the current system loss of about
40 percent would drop to 20 percent in 2010 and to only 10 percent in 2020.
These estimates are optimistic because it will require fixing most of the old
and leaky water mains as well as correcting all the institutional leakage
(illegal connection and incorrect billing). As a result, the deficit estimates
for the years 2010 and 2020 are definitely conservative ones.
Box 3: System loss in
some cities (1996)
| City | Systems loss |
| Lahore | 40% |
| Calcutta | 50% |
| Colombo | 35% |
| Katmandu | 40% |
| Bangkok | 38% |
| Manila | 44% |
The BIG
Project
Due to the rapidly growing population, increasing per
capita consumption and expansion of service areas of DWASA, the demand for
domestic water will increase to 4.6 Mm3/day in the year 2020. To meet this huge
demand, a big water supply project, namely the Saidabad Water Treatment Plant,
has been initiated by DWASA. The project will be implemented in four phases,
each with a design capacity of 225 ML/day. The implementation of the first phase
began in 1997 although the progress has been very slow so far. According to some
officials of DWASA, Phase I may not be completed before 2003. At this rate,
completion of the entire project may take another 10-15 years. Upon completion,
the treatment plant is expected to supply 0.9 Mm3 of water from the Sitalakhya
River every day. This project will effectively double the amount of water
currently supplied by DWASA.
Despite such ambitious efforts, the water deficit will
still continue to rise from 1.26 Mm3/day in 1996 to 2.75 Mm3/day in 2020. On a
positive note it can be said that although the absolute amount of deficit is
expected to increase, its share relative to the water demand will shrink. In
1990, only 30 percent of the water demand was met by DWASA, which will improve
to about 40 percent in 2020.
Can we pump more
groundwater?
Currently, about 95 percent of the water supplied
by DWASA comes from groundwater through 276 deep tubewells. This is serving only
about 65 percent of the domestic demand at 180 lpcd. To meet 100 percent of the
demand, DWASA needs some 350 deep tubewells. This level of groundwater
development, however, is not hydrologically feasible because the aquifer under
the city receives little recharge due to paving of the ground surface. Filling
up of the natural lakes and ponds, and encroachment of open spaces within the
city has made this problem even worse. Water levels in monitoring wells indicate
that the groundwater level has fallen by more than 20 m in the last decade
alone. This has not only reduced the productivity of the wells but also
increased the cost of water extraction. In fact, some experts believe that the
city cannot continue mining its groundwater for very long. Unless the aquifer is
artificially recharged, many of the deep tubewells may go dry in the near
future.
The efficiency gain
As the saying goes, there is a silver lining to every
dark cloud. The current level of system loss (40 percent) is an indication of
serious inefficiency in the water distribution system of DWASA. However,
identification of this problem should give DWASA a head start. DWASA should
immediately begin to identify the areas where most of the system loss is
occurring, particularly due to leakage. Necessary actions should then follow to
repair or replace the leaky water mains as appropriate. Eliminating the
institutional loss will be more difficult. For this, innovative options such as
leasing the billing and collection system to a private company or a cooperative
is already being tried out with encouraging results.
How
much water can be saved this way? The answer of course depends on the extent of
loss reduction. Let's assume that DWASA's estimate of 10 percent system loss by
2020 is achievable. Then even at a production level of 1 Mm3/day, the annual
savings will be about 110 Mm3 of water. At a rate of 300 liters per day, which
is much higher than the current per capita consumption of about 180 liters per
day, it will still serve 1 million additional individuals. Alternately, these
savings will be equivalent to having a fifth unit of the Saidabad Treatment
Plant, implemented for free (or at a small cost compared to the other units).
This definitely seems to be a goal worth pursuing.
Let the "price" magic work
We can also approach the issue from the demand
side of the story. The most effective type of demand management can be achieved
by charging the consumers a fair price for each unit of water
consumed.
Initially, when the resource is plentiful and the consumer base is
small, a simple flat fee system may work fine, as it is easier and less
expensive to implement. But when the resource becomes very scarce, as is the
case in Dhaka, a proportional full-cost pricing should be introduced to ensure
efficient use of water.
Currently 75percent of the legal water connections of
Dhaka are metered and the remaining 25 percent are charged monthly flat fees.
Clearly, there is some room for improvement in this area. The more difficult job
is to identify the illegal users who are enjoying a free ride or paying small
bribes to a group of corrupt DWASA officials. Bringing this group under the
metering scheme is likely to make a significant positive impact on the system
loss figure of DWASA.
In fact, many of the illegal connections are in the
slum areas where 30 to 40 percent of the city population lives. Independent
studies conducted in Bangladesh and elsewhere have consistently found that the
slum dwellers sometimes pay 2 to 5 times more for drinking water compared to the
people with legal access to the water supply system. Thus, extending legal
connections to the slums will not only reduce water loss but also reduce the
prevailing inequity in terms of access to safe water in the city.
We can make
a difference!
The most overlooked aspect of water management is the fact that
individual users can significantly contribute to reducing water demand by
conserving water at households. The relative amounts of water used for various
domestic purposes are shown in the figure at left.
It can be seen that almost
half of the total water consumption is going for bathing and toilet. The next
significant use is for washing that includes laundry and dish washing. Clearly
these are the areas where significant savings can be made.
For
example, cutting down the use of the bathtub, taking fewer long showers and
using smaller tanks for flushing the toilet can help save a lot of water. For
example, one-time use of a conventional toilet flush may cost 23 liters of
water. The newer, more water efficient tanks use only about 6 liters, which
means a savings of over 70 percent! A 20 percent reduction of water usage for
bathing and toilet can save nearly 0.2 Mm3 of water a day -- enough to serve an
additional 1 million people at a high daily consumption rate of 200 liters. With
a rapidly growing population, the savings will be much higher in the future.
Making way for innovations
Recently, a number of organizations such as
BUET, NSU, DWASA and NGO Forum, have started to explore the possibility of
harvesting rainwater and using this for household purposes.
The water quality
tests carried out at DWASA indicate that the rainwater quality is suitable for
drinking except for the first few minutes of shower. Experiments at BUET
indicate that Dhaka receives sufficient rain to satisfy the drinking water need
of an average family for six months. However, a large enough storage tank has to
be constructed first.
Rainwater can be used for bathroom and toilet without
any treatment (minimal filtering). Given the impending water crisis, a law
should be enacted requiring all new buildings to have a rainwater collection and
use system.
In the long
run, additional water treatment facilities will have to be set up in the western
part of the city. For example, the Turag River may be used to supply water to
the residents of Uttara. In short, the situation is not hopeless. However, we
have to plan ahead.
Let people participate
Historically, DWASA had a reactive rather
than a proactive policy towards dealing with the growing water demand. This was
because of the resource limitations and the low administrative priority given to
this very important organization. Things have changed in recent years and DWASA
is now looking at longer-term sustainable sources of water. The citizens of
Dhaka must help DWASA by conserving as much water as possible. They must also
pay the fair price for water. The very high level of "system loss" is a loss to
all of us as ultimately, the legal clients end up paying for the unauthorized
ones. DWASA should think of a more participatory management approach where
citizens' action groups, NGOs and interested private organizations Ð all will
participate in the decision making process. A better solution would be to
gradually convert DWASA into a limited company where interested people and
organizations can have a stake. This will enforce accountability and promote
efficiency - the two most important features of any successful
organization.
We know what the problems are and what short and long
term options we have. It is time that we start taking actions immediately
because for Dhaka, every drop counts!